Benevolent Institution - 56 South Hill Road
toxteth.net > institutions >  benevolent institution


The institution was fully titled " Liverpool Benevolent Society for reclaiming unfortunate females" and was founded in 1839. The so called 'unfortunate females', were young prostitutes. John Cropper jun. was the first President. Most such Homes were run by the various Church denominations, The Benevolent Institution was non-denominational, reflecting the Cropper's Quaker roots.

These sorts of places barely scratched the surface of the need within the City to "reclaim" young women. It is not surprising therefore to find several doing the same thing, even in the same area. Industrial Schools gave an education and job by training young girls as servants - several such places existed within Toxteth. The children at St Margaret's Orphanage, Upper Parliament Street went onto " Industrial Training" when they reached 14 years.

1839 Gore includes this institution, but no address is given, it was listed as  "The Society for reclaiming unfortunate females".

1841 Gore: shows "Benevolent House and Asylum for unfortunate females". 75 Rathbone Street. Mrs Mary Yates is Matron and Mr Alexander Sorley is Superintendent.

1845 and 1847 Gore: No entry

1848 and 1849 Gore: "Benevolent Society for reclaiming unfortunate females". Institution: 145 Mill St, Toxteth Park. The Slater's 1848 trade directory for Liverpool shows,"Benevolent Institution", 145 Mill Street, Mr. R. M. Marrack jun., secretary, Mary Yates, matron.

1851 Gore: Benevolent Institution, 17 Wellington Road , Toxteth Park. (this will will be from data gathered in 1850)

1858 Gore: Benevolent Institution, North Street, Toxteth Park. Miss Jane Sisley, Matron.

1860 Gore list the  'Benevolent Society for reclaiming unfortunate females' (in capital letters), at 140A North Street, Toxteth Park.

1861 The institution is in North Street (the property next to number 15) in the census for that year which shows a long list of 'servants' whilst many of the girls are shown simply with their initials. They have come from many different places. (only I census sheet is shown, there are others). Eliza White and Elizabeth Barr are the Matrons.

1869 Gore shows 'Benevolent Insitution: South Hill Road, Miss Jane Cragg Matron'. It is known to have been at No 56 South Hill Road, from at least 1870 still with Jane Cragg was matron. Jane Cragg was, in turn, a friend of the reformer, Josephine Butler.
 

Josephine Butler lived in South Hill, Park Road, Toxteth from 1866 to 1882. Her husband was the Reverend George Butler, Headmaster of Liverpool College in Everton at that time. Josephine Butler, had, in 1869, started a campaign against the Contagious Diseases Act and she was instrumental in it being repealed in 1886.

Josephine Butler initially had prostitutes from the Liverpool Workhouse living with her, but set up her own home for them somewhere near to where she lived. This has been tracked down by Paul Young and was in Menzies Street, about 100 yards away from her own home in South Hill.  It seems that the Benevolent Institution (founded in 1839) stayed briefly at Menzies Street before carrying along its own path, whilst the Menzies Street 'Home for Incurable'  progressed along separate lines.

The history of the latter is listed in the Liverpool Record Office notes (relating to the foundation of Princes Park Hospital), it was "a small house in Menzies Street, where in 1869 the social reformer Josephine Butler established a 'House of Rest' for women suffering from incurable chronic diseases. As the home grew, Josephine Butler handed over its running to a committee of ladies and there was a move to larger premises in Park Hill Road". However as recorded in Josephine Butler's biography, the first inhabitants of this 'House of Rest' appear to have been young prostitutes.


1871 The Belevolent Institution is at 56 South Hill Road in the census for that year. (One sheet shown). As for the 1869 entry, Jane Cragg is Matron.

In 1881 Gore shows this at No 56 South Hill Road close to the junction with Beloe Street. The plot of land actually on the junction remained undeveloped, the Benevolent Institution occupied the next plot of land and was adjacent to the vicarage and associated Mission Church of St Cleopas. It is called the 'Liverpool benevolent Society for Reclaining Fallen Women'. Miss Jane Grundy is then Matron. (Rev George Butler M.A. [and presumably Josephine] are now living at 390 Park Road which at this time is the junction with South Hill Road).

1884 The OS map shows the Institution as a rectangular building centred in its own grounds, but the 1893 and 1908 OS maps show the 'L' shaped wing running very close to the boundary.  Ken Roberts has suggested that this could reflect an extension built between 1884 and 1893.  If so, the need for this is a sad reflection on Victorian Liverpool.

1894 The address, title and matron are all exactly the same. Of note now however is that at No 58 the Rev. Webster Hall M.A. Vicar of St Cleopas' and surrogate is resident at 'Grecian House'. No 60 is just the other side of St Cleopas Mission Chapel (and houses the caretaker, Mrs Mary Bailey). Thus the position of the Benevolent Institution can be confirmed and applied to the map.  

1901 census : Benevolent Institution, South Hill Road, Matron Miss Jane Grundy. Miss Grundy had been assistant matron at North Street in the 1861 census so had been there for a very long time.

1907: Annual Report. Mrs William Rathbone patron.  Salaries £114, rent £50, Food costs £311. Gross income from laundry work £645.

1910 Miss Grundy is either about to retire or has retired and the Institution was about to close when it was bought by the Church of England Magdalen Society of Mount Vernon, Liverpool. It was then run as a two year training centre for the young women, fitting them for servant work etc. ( ref Liverpool Record Office H.364.2 DIO ).

1911 Miss Jane Grundy is still shown as matron in Gore although it is possible that their data was not totally up-to-date. The position and title of the Institution remain unchanged.

1926 No 56 is missing from Gore's directory, other adjacent properties are however numbered in the same way and little changed in function.

1930 An aerial photo of South Hill Road shows that the  Benevolent Home has been demolished in a general slum clearance of the Dingle area. (photo 352 ENG/2/9051) from Liverpool Record Office. The records for Gore do not show the Institute in 1936, 1946 and 1955. However Paul Young tells me that The Benevolent Institution side boundary wall was still there off South Hill Road in 2005.

6d

 External link to Josephine Butler
 Many thanks to Paul Young for undertaking the research, obtaining such full details of this institution and sharing this information so freely.
 Thanks also to Ken Roberts both for checking the maps and for his helpful contributions.